Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Federal court halts execution of Texas man who lawyers say is mentally ill

  1. A federal appeals court on Wednesday halted the execution of Texas death row inmate Scott Panetti, reported CNN. Panetti was scheduled to be executed later in the day.
  2. Panetti’s lawyers say he is severely mentally ill and has suffered from schizophrenia for 30 years.
  3. Panetti was convicted of shooting and killing his mother- and father-in-law — in front of his wife and daughter.
  4. Texas Governor Rick Perry and the Texas Board of Pardons and Parole refused to stay Panetti’s execution, despite pleas from more than a dozen conservative leaders.

Courts previously found Panetti fit for execution

The US Supreme Court ordered a reevaluation of Panetti’s mental health state in 2007. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which stayed Panetti’s execution on Wednesday, in 2013 found him competent enough to be executed.

Lawyers argue Panetti’s mental health state has deteriorated over time.

During his trial, Pannetti represented himself, dressed in a purple cowboy outfit, and called Jesus, John F. Kennedy, and the Pope to the stand.

58 percent of Americans oppose death penalty for the mentally ill

Americans oppose the death penalty for persons with mental illness by a margin of two to one, according to a new survey by Public Policy Polling. Out of 943 registered voters, 58 percent said they oppose capital punishment for people with mental illness, while only 28 percent supported it.

Panetti’s scheduled execution has renewed a nationwide conversation about the death penalty and mental health issues.

“This is a man that has been severely and profoundly ill since 12 years before the crime,” Ron Honberg, legal director for the National Alliance on Mental Illness, told USA Today. “It will be a travesty to proceed with this execution.”

Policy
Is Trump’s Justice Department trying to discredit itself?Is Trump’s Justice Department trying to discredit itself?
Policy

The DOJ used to avoid spectacles like the Louise Lucas raid.

By Ian Millhiser
Politics
What the Supreme Court still has left to decide this termWhat the Supreme Court still has left to decide this term
Politics

Democracy and Donald Trump dominate the Court’s remaining docket.

By Ian Millhiser
Politics
The Supreme Court seems a bit nervous about letting the police track you with your phoneThe Supreme Court seems a bit nervous about letting the police track you with your phone
Politics

The justices were concerned that the Trump administration is asking for too much in a major police surveillance case.

By Ian Millhiser
Politics
The Supreme Court will decide when the police can use your phone to track youThe Supreme Court will decide when the police can use your phone to track you
Politics

Chatrie v. United States asks what limits the Constitution places on the surveillance state in an age of cellphones.

By Ian Millhiser
Policy
Pam Bondi’s ouster makes Trump’s Justice Department even more dangerousPam Bondi’s ouster makes Trump’s Justice Department even more dangerous
Policy

The best thing about Bondi was her incompetence.

By Ian Millhiser
Culture
Me Too revealed a lot of villains. Why is Epstein the one we still care about?Me Too revealed a lot of villains. Why is Epstein the one we still care about?
Culture

How the Epstein story became an American parable.

By Constance Grady