Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Hillary Clinton’s opposition to Keystone XL is a political winner

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton raises her arms stands on stage during the New Hampshire Democratic Party Convention at the Verizon Wireless Center on September 19, 2015 in Manchester, New Hampshire.
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton raises her arms stands on stage during the New Hampshire Democratic Party Convention at the Verizon Wireless Center on September 19, 2015 in Manchester, New Hampshire.
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton raises her arms stands on stage during the New Hampshire Democratic Party Convention at the Verizon Wireless Center on September 19, 2015 in Manchester, New Hampshire.
Scott Eisen/Getty Images

The best way to tell that Hillary Clinton’s opposition to the Keystone XL pipeline is a political winner is to look at the reaction of her rivals for the Democratic presidential nomination.

They can’t blame her for agreeing with them, so they’re pointing out that they were there first.

Here’s Bernie Sanders:

As a senator who has vigorously opposed the Keystone pipeline from the beginning, I am glad that Secretary Clinton finally has made a decision and I welcome her opposition to the pipeline. Clearly it would be absurd to encourage the extraction and transportation of some of the dirtiest fossil fuel on the planet.

And here’s former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley, who noted Clinton has been later to the game on some other matters, too:

Leadership is about stating where you stand on critical issues, regardless of how they poll or focus group. On many of these issues, I staked out positions and got things done—even when they were politically unpopular. That’s what’s at stake in this election: the difference between conviction and convenience, and the gulf between actions and words.

In other words, there’s no room on the left to criticize her for the decision. Clinton, who was Secretary of State when the Keystone decision was first making its way through the Obama administration, telegraphed last week that she planned to make an announcement “soon.” She said she was “putting the White House on notice” that she couldn’t wait any longer, portraying her reticence as deference to the administration.

And let’s face it, the idea that Republican voters would cast ballots for Clinton because she was for the pipeline — or that Democrats or independents would vote against her because she opposes it — is pretty laughable.

Several of Clinton’s top donors, including Tom Steyer and Susie Tompkins Buell, are active in the environmental movement, and they have wanted her to come out against Keystone for some time. It’s an issue that matters a lot to that segment of the Democratic Party, and coming out against the pipeline takes a wedge issue away from Clinton’s current opponents — and perhaps Vice President Joe Biden, if he runs.

While most Republicans approve of the deal, it doesn’t rank with the economy and national security as the top issues that will turn votes in a general election. The bottom line: It matters to Clinton only in the Democratic primary, and she can only benefit from siding with the environmental movement.

More in Climate

Climate
Why the American Southeast is becoming a new hot spot for wildfiresWhy the American Southeast is becoming a new hot spot for wildfires
Climate

“Weather whiplash” is fueling blazes across Florida and the region.

By Kiley Price
Climate
The climate crisis is coming for your groceriesThe climate crisis is coming for your groceries
Climate

Extreme heat is already wiping out soy, coffee, berries, and Christmas trees. Farm animals and humans are suffering too.

By Ayurella Horn-Muller
Future Perfect
“I’m disgusted to be a human”: What to do when you hate your own species“I’m disgusted to be a human”: What to do when you hate your own species
Future Perfect

Yes, it hurts to be human right now. That’s actually the assignment.

By Sigal Samuel
Climate
Levees can no longer save New OrleansLevees can no longer save New Orleans
Climate

The city is part of “the most physically vulnerable coastline in the world.”

By Oliver Milman
Future Perfect
The old tech that could help stop the next airborne pandemicThe old tech that could help stop the next airborne pandemic
Future Perfect

Glycol vapors, explained.

By Shayna Korol
Climate
The exploding costs of fighting US wildfiresThe exploding costs of fighting US wildfires
Climate

From taxes on nicotine to hotel rooms, states are looking for ways to pay the skyrocketing bill.

By Kylie Mohr