Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

Bernie Sanders’s fans show Hillary Clinton what negative “tone” is really like

Gerardo Mora/Getty Images

Hillary Clinton’s campaign says Bernie Sanders needs to tone it down. But Sanders’s supporters have one question: Tone down for what?

A top Clinton aide’s chiding comments about Sanders’s “negative” tone have prompted Sanders supporters to drudge up all their Clinton attacks on Twitter with the viral hashtag #ToneDownForWhat (a reference to DJ Snake’s song “Turn Down for What”).

The hashtag formed after Clinton’s strategist Joel Benenson said the campaign was weary of participating in a debate because the Sanders campaign told the Washington Post the team was polling which issues would cause the most damage in the New York primary.

“Sen. Sanders doesn’t get to decide when we debate, particularly when he’s running a very negative campaign against us. Let’s see if he goes back to the kind of tone he said we going to set early on. If he does that, then we’ll talk about debates,” Benenson said on CNN Monday.

On Tuesday, Clinton said she was open to a debate in Brooklyn while on the campaign trail in Wisconsin. But that hasn’t stopped Sanders voters from defending their tone.

What are Sanders supporters not toning it down for?

While Sanders’s people might be polling different attacks, it seems like his supporters are doing the legwork for his campaign. The hashtag includes critiques of Clinton’s stance on issues ranging from Wall Street to her high speaking fee costs and her position on fracking.

Here are some of their posts:

And then there’s Rand Paul, who seems to just be trolling the whole thing:

We’ve seen this grassroots effort from Sanders’s people before

Similarly, Sanders supporters engaged Twitter users in another anti-Clinton social campaign with the #HillarySoProgressive hashtag earlier in February when the two candidates engaged in an ideological debate over Clinton’s commitment to progressive values.

It might be a testament to Sanders’s young voter base that they can swiftly and nimbly turn the two candidates’ mini feuds into viral-ready hashtags. The is-she-or-isn’t-she-progressive debate played a strong role in the earlier Democratic debates.

Although Clinton is expected to win big in her home state of New York, which has 247 delegates, her camp is keeping an eye on Sanders, who, 230 delegates behind Clinton, is making a real push in New York.

“We’ll be the underdog, but being the underdog in New York is not the worst situation in politics,” Tad Devine, Sanders’s chief strategist, told the Washington Post. “We’re going to make a real run for it.”

More in Politics

Podcasts
The Supreme Court abortion pills case, explainedThe Supreme Court abortion pills case, explained
Podcast
Podcasts

How Louisiana brought mifepristone back to SCOTUS.

By Peter Balonon-Rosen and Sean Rameswaram
Politics
Trump’s China policy is nearly the exact opposite of what everyone expectedTrump’s China policy is nearly the exact opposite of what everyone expected
Politics

As Trump heads to China, attention and resources are being shifted from Asia to yet another war in the Middle East.

By Joshua Keating
Politics
Are far-right politics just the new normal?Are far-right politics just the new normal?
Politics

Liberals are preparing for a longer war with right-wing populists than they once expected.

By Zack Beauchamp
The Logoff
Flavored vapes doomed Trump’s FDA headFlavored vapes doomed Trump’s FDA head
The Logoff

Why Marty Makary is out at the FDA, briefly explained.

By Cameron Peters
Politics
Virginia Democrats’ irresponsible new plan to save their gerrymanderVirginia Democrats’ irresponsible new plan to save their gerrymander
Politics

Democrats just handed the Supreme Court’s Republicans a loaded weapon.

By Ian Millhiser
The Logoff
Can Trump lower gas prices?Can Trump lower gas prices?
The Logoff

What suspending the gas tax would mean for you, briefly explained.

By Cameron Peters