Skip to main content

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Join now

The far right chose virtue signaling over legislating. That caused the shutdown.

Immigration restrictionists killed any chance at a compromise.

Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) makes an announcement on the introduction of the Reforming American Immigration for a Strong Economy (RAISE) Act in the Roosevelt Room at the White House on August 2, 2017, in Washington, DC.
Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) makes an announcement on the introduction of the Reforming American Immigration for a Strong Economy (RAISE) Act in the Roosevelt Room at the White House on August 2, 2017, in Washington, DC.
Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) makes an announcement on the introduction of the Reforming American Immigration for a Strong Economy (RAISE) Act in the Roosevelt Room at the White House on August 2, 2017, in Washington, DC.
Zach Gibson - Pool/Getty Images

On Thursday, I wrote that President Trump’s remarks on immigration from “shithole” countries was emblematic of a larger, more pervasive, and more dangerous viewpoint on the intersection of immigration and race:

Trump isn’t just expressing what some conservatives view as “politically incorrect” sentiments. He — and, importantly, members of his staff — is embracing what used to be a fringe theory held by the furthest of the far right — one that holds that white people are being systematically “erased” by their inferiors, and thus require an influx of white babies and new white immigrants (and the exclusion of nonwhite immigrants) to survive.

Now, that viewpoint has resulted in the shutdown of the federal government.

Immigration restrictionists got us into this mess

The current debacle on the Hill has markedly little to do with concerns about border security — it’s about halting immigration, especially from nonwhite countries.

In the final days and hours before the government shut down, Trump torpedoed a bipartisan compromise that was Congress’s best shot at passing a package that would keep the government open and do something about the DACA program Trump ended last year, but wanted fixed. The compromise would have given Trump much of what he has stated he wants out of immigration reform, including a border wall and an end to “diversity visas.” And it included provisions that he himself favored less than four months ago.

Instead, Trump landed here:

Trump had turned toward the views of restrictionists in Congress like Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR), whom the president invited to the “shithole” meeting. In the White House, senior policy adviser Stephen Miller has long influenced Trump’s attitudes on immigration policy.

The silent hand of Miller on Trump’s view toward DACA was notable enough that Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) mentioned it to MSNBC, saying that Miller’s approach had “no viability.”

The GOP is supporting policies that do more virtue signaling than legislating

Breitbart fired right back at Graham, running a piece that called him “pro-amnesty,” while referring to Cotton as “the heir to Jeff Sessions’ pro-American immigration reform agenda.” Cotton has said that the “American people” favor Trump’s — and, more importantly, his own — “economic nationalist approach” to immigration, one that favors massive cuts on legal immigration and harsh penalties on legal immigrants and DACA recipients, and criminalizing the status of undocumented immigrants, who currently are in violation of civil law, not criminal law.

The language used by sites like Breitbart make crystal clear that this is all about demographic mythmaking and fearmongering. In the article describing Cotton’s desired immigration policy, Breitbart’s John Binder writes:

By 2023, the Center for Immigration Studies estimates that the legal and illegal immigrant population of the U.S. will make up nearly 15 percent of the entire U.S. population.

The Center for Immigration Studies was founded by John Tanton, who has a history of embracing eugenicist policies (he founded a pro-eugenics organization, the Society for Genetic Education, or SAGE) and was reported as telling a friend, “for European-American society and culture to persist requires a European-American majority, and a clear one at that.”

Now Tanton’s allies — and Cotton, Steve King, Bob Goodlatte, and, most of all, Donald Trump — are attempting to put these ideas into immigration policy. And they wonder why Democrats aren’t interested.

See More:

More in Politics

Podcasts
The Supreme Court abortion pills case, explainedThe Supreme Court abortion pills case, explained
Podcast
Podcasts

How Louisiana brought mifepristone back to SCOTUS.

By Peter Balonon-Rosen and Sean Rameswaram
Politics
Trump’s China policy is nearly the exact opposite of what everyone expectedTrump’s China policy is nearly the exact opposite of what everyone expected
Politics

As Trump heads to China, attention and resources are being shifted from Asia to yet another war in the Middle East.

By Joshua Keating
Politics
Are far-right politics just the new normal?Are far-right politics just the new normal?
Politics

Liberals are preparing for a longer war with right-wing populists than they once expected.

By Zack Beauchamp
The Logoff
Flavored vapes doomed Trump’s FDA headFlavored vapes doomed Trump’s FDA head
The Logoff

Why Marty Makary is out at the FDA, briefly explained.

By Cameron Peters
Politics
Virginia Democrats’ irresponsible new plan to save their gerrymanderVirginia Democrats’ irresponsible new plan to save their gerrymander
Politics

Democrats just handed the Supreme Court’s Republicans a loaded weapon.

By Ian Millhiser
The Logoff
Can Trump lower gas prices?Can Trump lower gas prices?
The Logoff

What suspending the gas tax would mean for you, briefly explained.

By Cameron Peters